What Razor Gives The Closest Shave? An Honest Comparison


What Razor Gives The Closest Shave? An Honest Comparison

Men have plenty of options but what razor gives the closest shave? Is the closest shave even offered by a razor or by an electric shaver?

Let’s take a closer look at each option including the pros and cons of each.

Electric Shaver

My 3-head rotary electric shaver with trimming tool.
My 3-head rotary head electric shaver with pop-up trimming tool.

Pros

  • Wet/dry options available for some models meaning you can shave your bare skin or you can shave with shaving cream in the shower. Your choice.
  • Choose between rotating head shavers or foil head shavers. Each have benefits.
  • Portable. Easy to take on a trip and you can normally bring it on a plane in your carry on.
  • Newest models have features like pivoting heads, floating heads and trimmer for a closer and more comfortable shave.
  • Has a lift and cut system that lifts hairs and cuts them for a closer shave that lasts longer than other shaving methods.

Cons

  • Lift and cut systems can cause ingrown hairs since they cut hairs below the skin.
  • Electric shavers can cause skin irritation.
  • Might be difficult to use in tight spots ie. neck, jawline, under the ear.
  • Not the best choice for shaving your head as it’s very time-consuming (I speak from experience).

Disposable Razor

My disposable 3 blade razor.
My disposable 3 blade razor.

Pros

  • Offers a close shave when used properly.
  • Fairly quick to use even when you add the time to apply shaving cream.
  • A good choice for shaving your face and head. It’s versatile.
  • Razors and shaving creams are easy to find.

Cons

  • Costly over time as you have to replace razor blades and buy shaving cream.
  • You can cut and nick your skin since the razor directly touches your skin.
  • Ingrown hairs can occur especially from 2+ blade razors that lift and cut hairs.

Double Edge Razor

What Razor Gives The Closest Shave? A Double Edge (DE) razor blade is a good start.
Double Edge (DE) razor blade. This is the actual handle and the blade itself sits inside the head of the handle which screws open and shut.

Pros

  • It has a single blade (double edged) so less chance of skin irritation that multi-blade razors often cause.
  • Double edge means both sides of the blade can be used (lasts longer) but you use only one edge at a time!
  • It cuts hair at skin level for a close shave but reduces if not eliminates the chances of ingrown hairs.
  • Razor blade replacements are generally cheap. The technology has been around for 100+ years so all old patents are long since expired ie. they can be easily and cheaply produced.

Cons

  • Requires a razor handle which costs money, more than a typical disposable razor handle costs.
  • Needs some skill, moreso than a disposable razor, as you have to hold the blade at a 30 degree angle.

Straight Razor

Shaving with a straight razor.
A selection of (mostly) straight razors.

Pros

  • Offers a very close shave.
  • A cheap option when you think that you don’t replace the blade as often as disposable razor blades.

Cons

  • Takes the most time to use and master. You need to shave slowly and prep skin in advance.
  • Requires the most skill of the above-mentioned options.
  • Less availability than electric shavers, DE razors and disposable razors.

Conclusion: What Razor Gives The Closest Shave

  • The main options for shaving are electric shaver, disposable/cartridge razors, DE razor and straight razor.
  • Electric shavers are fairly versatile and cost effective over time.
  • Disposable razors are easy to find and use but need to be replaced regularly.
  • A Double Edge razor cuts hair at skin level reducing the chance of ingrown hairs.
  • A straight razor is the least common option these days and requires the most skill to use.

Let us know in the comments below which shaving option(s) you use and which ones you like the most and least!

Carl Mueller

I'm a bald guy with beard (goatee) who blogs about shaving, head shaving, style and grooming ideas for men.

Recent Posts